
Most people have experienced Charles Dickens’ A Christmas Carol in some form, as the 1843 novella is one of the most adapted literary works of all time, and horror filmmaker Ti West has now put his spin on it.
The story is largely the same, detailing the story of how the misanthropic miser Ebenezer Scrooge (Johnny Depp) spends the night before Christmas being visited by three spirits from whom he must learn lessons in order to change his cruel ways lest he wants to end up like his old business partner Jacob Marley (Ian McKellen), who is having a less than stellar time in the afterlife.
With West at the helm, the film leans more heavily into the story’s inherent horror elements than most adaptations, with McKellen’s take on Marley being particularly biting, while the haunting styling of Andrea Riseborough’s ethereal Ghost of Christmas Past makes for a stunning visual, which is subsequently contrasted by Martell Tillman’s imposing and brash Ghost of Christmas Present.
Another thing West has showcased throughout his career is how he understands the ins and outs of horror filmmaking through the ages, adding an extra layer of authenticity and craftmanship to his efforts that has made them stand out in the horror landscape over the years.
With Ebenezer, this results in a film with a cozily creepy visual style, albeit it comes across as having been under too many studio constraints to allow the filmmaker to genuinely put his fingerprints on Paramount’s big holiday offering.
There will be those who will automatically give Ebenezer a miss solely due to Depp’s involvement, while others will be curious to see his spin on the character, albeit his portrayal of Scrooge has rightly been the primary cause for concern with this adaptation, as the majority of his performances after the success of Pirates of the Caribbean: The Curse of the Black Pearl have been frequently underwhelming and occasionally obnoxious, often feeling like some sort of uninspired variation of his Jack Sparrow character.
Thankfully, his take on Scrooge is not as jarring as feared, however, how immersed he is in the character seems dependent on whom he is sparring with on screen, his scenes with McKellen being among the film’s best, but once the other spirits enter the picture, Depp ultimately fails to fully sell his portrayal of Scrooge, not least because he simply does not adequately convey the character’s almost impenetrable reluctance to change his ways, leaving Depp’s version convinced to be a better man before the first spirit is even through with him.
For the casual enjoyer of festive films, Ebenezer is perfectly enjoyable as a slightly darker take on a classic tale than we are used to seeing in mainstream cinema, but for the purists who are intimately familiar with the original work, there are some alterations to the narrative that profoundly change some of the story’s core elements and by extension erasing the meaning and lessons they are meant to carry.
As such, while Ebenezer is nowhere near as humbug as many feared and in fact has a lot of things going for it, Depp is ultimately the least interesting thing about it and could easily have been replaced by another actor, proving once again that there has been little point in making film adaptations of Dickens’ classic since 1992’s The Muppet Christmas Carol.
Verdict: 4 out of 10.







